Peanut Butter Making Machine – How to Pick the Best

Peanut Butter Making Machine - How to Pick the Best

Peanut butter is a delicious spread made from roasted peanuts and is a part of the beloved breakfast staple, PB&J. It is high in protein and contains healthy monosaturated fats.

But the store-bought peanut butter contains refined oils, unhealthy fats, and added preservatives. So, what if we told you that you could make peanut butter at home in less than a minute with no added oils or sugar?

Take a look at the article below to learn how to make peanut butter at home and our top picks for a peanut butter maker. Let’s begin!

Things to Look for in A Peanut Butter Maker

After doing our due diligence, we have made a list of some factors to consider before investing in a peanut butter maker, so you know exactly what to look for:

From The Web

1. Size

The size refers to how big the device and the jar are. 

Subscribe to our Blog!

Get all the latest articles, News and product recommendations sent straight to your email inbox

Hidden Content

The machine itself should be compact for ease of storage. If it has detachable parts, put them all in the hollow space, so they don’t take up space on your kitchen counter.

The size of the jar depends on the quantity of peanut butter you want to make in one batch. If everyone in your family is a fan of homemade nut butter, go for a larger size because you don’t want to make peanut butter every day, however easy it is.

2. BPA-Free Plastic

BPA, or bisphenol A, is harmful to humans, especially to the developing brain of a child. 

It is said to have negative effects on your mood and alter brain functions. Plastic uses BPA in its construction. Since most jars are made from plastic, a food processor can pose a health risk.

So, it is necessary to make sure that the machine you buy is made from BPA-free plastic for your family’s safety.

3. Motor

If your purpose is to make pistachio, peanut, or almond butter, you will need a food processor with a powerful motor. The motor should have a minimum power of 400 watts.

A high-powered motor will ensure that the peanut butter is smooth and there are no chunks. It will also take less time.

So, spring for a processor with a powerful motor, but make sure it is not too noisy.

4. Efficiency

The efficiency of the machine depends on its performance and reliability. It should be sturdy and durable.

Processors also come with grind speed settings, which allow you to adjust the speed according to the number of peanuts you have put inside the container.

5. Blade Performance

Make sure that the peanut butter maker you choose has sharp slicing blades. It won’t matter how powerful the motor is unless the blades are sharp enough to cut through peanuts.

Some food processors and blenders come with different detachable blade options, and they are each suitable for different types of foods and have unique functions.

How Does A Peanut Butter Maker Work?

For making peanut butter at home, you can use a high-power food processor or mill. Food processors are perfect for large nuts such as peanuts and almonds.

A peanut butter machine will consist of a bowl, sharp blades, and a feeding tube. All you need to do is fill the jar with roasted peanuts and pulse the grinder. The blades will shred the peanuts into crumbs.

After a few minutes of grinding, you will see the natural oils of the peanut start to separate. You should stop once every 30 seconds to mix the ground peanuts and oil. This will also remove any peanuts stuck in the blades.

You should let the mixture sit for a while, giving the machine time to cool down. If you grind for too long, the blades will heat up due to friction and could damage the machine.

Keep grinding until you get a paste of the desired consistency. You can also add salt or natural sweeteners for more flavor.

Peanut Butter Machine: Our Top 3 Picks

Here is a buying guide to help you land the perfect peanut butter maker for you and your family. You cannot go wrong with any one of these devices!  

Cuisinart DFP-14BCNY Food Processor

The Cuisinart 14-cup food processor is our number one pick for making peanut butter at home. Its pros are:

  • Made from BPA-free material
  • Comes with a stainless steel chopping blade, a medium slicing disc, and a serrated slicing disc
  • Has a large feeding tube that can fit almost all kinds of foods
  • Has a heavy-duty 720-watt motor for a fast and easy function

Braun FP3020 Food Processor

The Braun FP3020 food processor has a capacity of 12 cups or 2.8 L. It is an energy-efficient machine with stainless steel blades. Its pros are:

  • Has an ultra-quiet, powerful motor of 600 watts and 110 voltage
  • Its accessories include 7 blade attachments, a juicer, and a chopper
  • All parts are dishwasher-friendly, which makes cleaning easier
  • Has 11 different speed settings, and you can start directly at any speed

Hamilton Beach Stack & Snap Food Processor

Hamilton Beach Stack & Snap Food Processor

The Hamilton food processor is much more affordable than other options. It comes with a 14-cup capacity and a 4-cup capacity bowl, which gives you more control over quantity. Its pros are:

  • BPA-free material
  • Has 3-speed settings with a powerful 500-watt motor
  • Has a large feeding tube, which will help you save time on pre-chopping
  • Comes with 2 stainless steel blades, a dough kneading blade, and a reversible disc for shredding and slicing

FAQ Section

Here, we have answered some commonly asked questions about homemade peanut butter:

1. Is it cheaper to make your own nut butter or buy it?

Yes, homemade nut butter is about 20% cheaper than store-bought. It is the best choice in terms of savings and health benefits as well.

Subscribe to our Blog!

Get all the latest articles, News and product recommendations sent straight to your email inbox

Hidden Content

2. How long does homemade nut butter last?

Homemade nut butter can last for up to 2 months in the refrigerator. Do not keep it at room temperature in the pantry.


If you didn’t make peanut butter at home before because you didn’t have a commercial peanut butter machine or thought the process would be harrowing, there is nothing stopping you now!

Using a food processor from our top 3 choices, you can make all kinds of nut spreads, from cashew butter to pistachio butter. They all have glorious reviews on Amazon and will definitely be worth your money!

Best Rice Storage Container and How to Pick

Best Rice Storage Container and How to Pick

Here's How to Find the Best Cake Leveler

Here’s How to Find the Best Cake Leveler